These flavors may be retired, but they’re never forgotten
Some favorites return for special events and seasonal menus- keep an eye out!
Orange Cookie: The signature recipe that started it all. A delicate, citrus-forward cookie crafted with fresh-squeezed orange juice and vibrant zest — light, bright, and utterly irresistible.
Peach Cobbler Cookie: A seasonal delicacy; each cookie is crowned with a fresh white peach reduction and a homemade cinnamon crumble for added crisp. Finished with a silky vanilla-cinnamon-nutmeg drizzle that melts into the crumble offering a comforting blend of spices.
Coffee Cookie: A refined coffee-forward cookie crowned with a velvety chocolate and espresso glaze. Crafted for those who appreciate the bold, aromatic depth of a perfectly pulled shot — in every bite.
Brown Sugar Pancake Cookie: Filled with Oreo’s BTS Brown Sugar Cookies but elevated with Blissful Butter’s signature flair. Sweet, with a subtle hint of cinnamon and maple- be sure to grab these while they last!
Apple Pie A La Mode Cookie: The beloved pairing of Oreos and Blissful Butter returns in a show-stopping seasonal treat. Sweet Apple Pie Oreos meet the nutty depth of browned butter and a touch of Bliss, finished with creamy white chocolate chips—an irresistible, cozy dessert that celebrates the change of seasons.
Salted Caramel Cookie: Homemade buttery caramel tempered with a whisper of sea salt tops off a perfect sugar cookie to sharpen the sweetness and lift the flavors. The result is familiar yet elevated: childhood comfort re-imagined with grown-up balance and a refined finish.
Pistachio Cookie: A perfectly balanced pistachio cookie paired with a luscious, house-made pistachio crème icing. Subtly nutty, elegantly sweet, and crafted for those with a refined palate.
Vampire Cheesecake Cookie: A hauntingly rich chocolate cookie cloaks a silky blood red cheesecake heart, finished with a bloody good chocolate drizzle.
Chocolate Covered Pumpkin Cake: A perfectly carved pumpkin cake cloaked in a rich chocolate shell.
Dirt Cup Cookie: A spine-tingling favorite! A deep midnight chocolate cookie, slathered in gooey :mud" frosting and showered with Oreo and crushed peanut crumbs. Topped with a wiggly gummy worm for a delightfully creepy finish.
Marshmallow Crispie Cookie: A gooey spider-web cookie- Rice Krispies and marshmallow weave together into a buttery, homemade classic for a frightfully delicious Halloween treat.
Pistachio Monster Cookie: Adorably scary: a delicate sugar cookie crowned with a luxuriously creamy homemade pistachio frosting. Keep your eye(s) on these, they’ll be gone soon!
Peanut Butter and Mallow Sammie: A fluffer‑nutter lover’s dream: two tender, melt‑in‑your‑mouth peanut‑butter cookies embrace a velvety homemade peanut‑butter filling and a cloud‑soft layer of marshmallow.
Apple Cider Cookie: A soft-baked cookie studded with crisp, freshly diced apples, warming cinnamon and nutmeg, and finished with a glossy, house-made apple cider glaze — a cozy, inventive twist on orchard-fresh comfort.
Pumpkin Chai Latte Cookie: Thick, pumpkin cookies rolled in a cinnamon‑sugar blend, crowned with our silky homemade coffee glaze and a dusting of fragrant chai spice. Cozy café flavors meet comforting bakery warmth—your favorite fall latte, reinvented as a blissful cookie.
Sticky Toffee Pudding Cookie: This popular British dessert has been reinvented into your new favorite cookie: Deep sweetness warmed with cinnamon and nutmeg spices, finely chopped Medjool dates, and nutty browned butter. It is soft and gooey with a caramel center, bits of dark and white chocolate, and drizzled with a toffee finish. Elevate your expectations with this unique cookie recipe.
Cookies & Scream Cookie: The beloved pairing of Oreos and Blissful Butter returns in another seasonal treat. Spooky orange cream Oreos overflow Blissful Butter’s trademark Cookies & Cream recipe- hauntingly delicious.